This is the improved version. I am in the process of editing the novel before sending it off to beta readers. Overall, grammar and sentence structure has been improved, as well as smaller improvements to accompany those.
Overall, this prologue now has a much better feel to it. 
--
Chapter One: [link]I originally wrote this last Thursday, but decided to refrain from posting it until today, December 23rd, because it is my third anniversary here on deviantArt and this piece means a lot to me, which made it the perfect time to post.
Yes, for many it is still the 22nd; I'm posting this at nearly 00:30 in Germany, so for me it is already the 23rd.On September 30th, 2008, I started writing a novel. Over the past years that novel has expanded into a multi-part series. Even so, progress on it has halted for over a year as my writing matured and I found myself realizing the novel was... immature, poorly written and not at all up to my current standards. There were glaring plotholes that I needed to fix, but was unaware of how to do so.
Nearly a month ago, my muse helped me solve that problem. This prologue is the start of the first novel in the series, which will not focus on the main character himself; instead, it focuses on his origin. This was what I needed to fill in the blanks, fix the errors and expand it into what it should truly be.
This is my most elaborate, most dear project.
I understand that the content of this novel may not be something more religious people would like to read. However, I assure you that I do not mean to offend anyone with what I have written, nor do I intend for it to do so.
Opinions as well as feedback are greatly appreciated.
Does the story play out well enough? How is the language, structure, details and setting? Is there anything you see that could be improved on?This story, characters, plotline and everything related to it are copyrighted to me and may not be used, edited, sold, or redistributed without my express written permission.
Although I understand that this is only a prologue and that the main character has not even been revealed yet, I can say that I find the prologue itself to be quite interesting indeed. You introduce a number of different concepts to the final battle between God and Lucifer that make for a very different kind of story than what is described in the Revelation. The battle here is depicted as being identical to a battle between humans, in that the angels on both sides seem to be the only participants (as Christ isn’t even mentioned) and are depicted as quite mortal, Lucifer’s power is depicted as consisting of magic used in spells rather than as God-given abilities and he has come up with a way for evil to continue even after his ultimate defeat. Incidentally, I am curious as to whether Lucifer is understood in this story to continue to exist in Hell after physical death or not; the way I am reading this prologue causes me to think that his death was meant to be his absolute end.
Lucifer’s characterization is strong, especially considering that only so much occurs in the prologue. To the very end he remains the controlled deceiver, the one who favors his fair angelic appearance along with smooth, deliberate words to attempt to manipulate the thoughts and emotions of even one so high and holy as a faithful archangel. Not even his impending demise causes him to love who and what he is and does any less, and he chooses to squeeze out every last drop of pleasure he can in his final moments, seeking to plant a seed of pain in Michael rather than recognize the meaninglessness of his rebellion.
My opinion on Michael’s characterization has changed the more I think about him in this piece. Originally I did not think of him extremely highly because I didn’t find it very difficult to think of ways to respond to Lucifer’s taunts and it seemed odd to me that he could not think of them himself; for example, when Lucifer asked if it were not the Lord who commanded Michael to kill him, Michael could have responded that God was merely repaying him for his own deeds. After considering Michael’s given response further, though, I think it ultimately was fitting as well and that I was simply being too critical originally. In the end I think you have characterized Michael extremely well; he is shown as being completely faithful to God, very self-controlled (even when he became angry with Lucifer, it was wholly appropriate) and is sincerely caring, even to his greatest enemy. Even then there is not a hint of pride or self-righteousness on Michael’s part, so I believe you have depicted him admirably.
As far as the setting goes, I think that the barren desert works perfectly. In my opinion the frequency of references to the sand, wind etc. is just right; it is low enough to create the sense that this is a place of emptiness and desolation, emphasizing the devastation of the preceding battle, yet it is high enough that the reader is able to continue to picture the setting without any difficulty.
Moving on to matters of grammar, punctuation, etc., while I didn’t feel like errors were especially frequent while reading the story, I did still find a number of places that ought to be addressed. Tell me if there are any you don’t understand or particularly disagree with.
The upper part of his robes had been shredded and hung passed his waist – a large gash tore across his chest and bled profusely. – Change “passed” to “past” and change the hyphen to a semicolon.
His left wing twitched and hung limp, and he cringed in pain, knowing full well that multiple bones were broken. – Use a semicolon after “limp” and remove the word “and.” The sentence seems to flow better this way.
The battle he ignited had stolen one of the few things that defined whom he was. – Change “whom” to “who.” I could be wrong about this one, but “whom” really doesn’t sound right to me here.
Despite his wounds, the man, no more than twenty-five years, kept his composure. – Remove the comma after “man” and insert the word “appearing” after it. Add the words “of age” after “years” and remove the comma. I’m assuming you’re only trying to describe Lucifer’s appearance rather than his actual age.
The battleground had fallen into silence, though once raged with the fight between both sides – the rebels and the holy. – Add the words “it had just” after “though” and remove the word “once.” My understanding is that the battle had just taken place, so this would make that clearer.
“Lucifer,” another man stated, taking a step towards the injured one. “How could you betray our Lord?” – Change “stated” to “started.” Regardless of which word you meant to write, “started” would make more sense because simply saying “Lucifer” is not a statement and because Michael was just starting to speak.
The strain took its toll on him and he flinched, expression warping to show both his physical and mental strain. – Add the word “his” before “expression.”
Slowly, the tremors raking Lucifer's body passed and he removed the hand from his mouth, proceeding to take several deep breaths whilst ignoring the anguish that simple task caused him. – Change “whilst” to “while.” Again, I’m not absolutely certain about this, but I really don’t think “whilst” is the correct word here. If there’s a rule you know of that would explain this, let me know.
Wiping the blood that covered his hand onto his robes, Lucifer rose to his feet and stumbled, though regained his balance. “Tell me, Michael,” Lucifer spoke in a ragged tone, yet resolve overcame his fatigue. – Add the words “he quickly” after “though.” Change the comma after “Michael” to an ellipsis. “Tell me, Michael…” serves as its own sentence here.
He sensed the attack before it hit him, but was in no condition to dodge. – Add “it” after “dodge.”
He felt as if sharp blades pieced his skin – once, twice, never ending. – Change “pieced” to “pierced.”
No matter that his life would soon end, Lucifer had taken matters into his own hands and knew that, even after his death, his memory and strength would remain in the world. – Remove the comma after “that.”
He was aware his time grew short; the strength of the divine warrior he once was dissipated and for the first time, Lucifer sensed his mortality and realized what humans felt every day they lived. – Add the word “that” after “aware.” Add a comma after “dissipated” and remove the comma before “Lucifer.”
In closing, this piece seems to work excellently as a prologue based on its own merits, understanding that I have not read on in the story itself. You've written it in an extremely descriptive manner, going into tremendous detail both with the visuals and with everything Lucifer is thinking and experiencing. It is quite controversial in that it does significantly reimagine a biblical narrative (effectively rewriting it entirely if a new evil figure comes after Lucifer is vanquished), but I did find it interesting and imaginative.
The first thing I would bring to your attention is the over emphasizing of the setting. In the first line:
"Bitter winds ripped across the gritty plain, casting grains of sand into the air."
Could read
"The bitter winds ripped grains of sand across the plain."
This is a more concise version of the same sentiment (this is all of course in my opinion, and I cannot stress that enough). I would consider a different verb than ripped perhaps. What you're trying to do with how you have the scene set up currently is create a very specific scene, but you overemphasizing it. Tone it down a little and let the reader paint a picture along with you.
The one thing that did bother me to no end, however, is the constant reference to the angels as "men" or "man". This is the only real problem I have with the story, as they are not men.
Aside from that, there are just syntax errors, and common grammatical mistakes.
For instance:
"The sand beneath his bare feet caressed his skin,(I really like that image of it caressing him) though colored crimson as blood trailed from many wounds and soaked into it."
After though simply read rough without a noun or pronoun to reference to. "though it was colored crimson by the blood soaking into it." (another example of how it can be more concise).
One suggestion I would make is to lose the idea of Lucifer suppressing his pain via some magical property. I'd just let him be in pain, perhaps even feed off of it, to add more to his personality. As it stands it sort of feels "anime"ish, which isn't a bad thing by any means, but it also feels "epic"ish, and its working too hard trying to be both.
Other than that it just needs a little proofreading. I'm excited to see where you can take this, and I think you're talented as a writer. You're just up against hard company, and this kind of story is always going to be compared to epics such as Paradise Lost or possibly even Frank Perreti. Keep up the good work
The Artist has requested Critique on this Artwork
Please sign up or login to post a critique.